Key Takeaways

  • Reinstatement works are what a tenant does at the end of a factory tenancy to hand the unit back in the condition the agreement requires: usually removing its own alterations, repairing damage and returning a clean, empty unit. The signed agreement and the consent letters decide the scope, not custom.
  • Get the landlord's written consent before any renovation, and treat it as separate from council approval. Altering a building without the council's written permission can bring a fine of up to RM25,000 and a court order to alter or demolish (Street, Drainage and Building Act 1974, s.70(11)).
  • What you fix to the building generally becomes part of the land: the National Land Code defines land to include "all things attached to the earth or permanently fastened to anything attached to the earth" (section 5). Agree in writing which items you may take away, which stay and whether anything is paid for.
  • Handing back the keys is not enough. In a 2017 High Court case, a tenant that returned the keys without restoring the units was held not to have given vacant possession and was ordered to reinstate them, with double rent under section 28(4) of the Civil Law Act 1956 (Hong Poh Teck v Effort Ezy).
  • A landlord can keep part of the deposit for reinstatement only as the agreement allows and with evidence, and fair wear and tear is not the tenant's cost. A forfeiture is tested against "reasonable compensation" under section 75 of the Contracts Act 1950.

Most factory and warehouse tenants change the unit they rent: offices and partitions, a mezzanine, racking, extra power, a cold room, exhaust ducts. Those changes come back as a bill on the last day of the tenancy, and the argument usually ends up being about the deposit. This guide explains, for tenants and landlords of industrial property in Malaysia, what reinstatement works cover, when you need the landlord's consent, who owns the renovation when the tenancy ends, what condition the law and the agreement expect, and how the deposit is settled. It is general information, not legal advice: have a lawyer read your own agreement.

What are reinstatement works in a factory tenancy?

Reinstatement works (also called make good works) are the removal, repair and cleaning a tenant carries out so the premises match the condition the tenancy agreement requires at the end of the term. The obligation comes from the reinstatement clause, which commonly asks the tenant to yield up the premises in good and tenantable repair, fair wear and tear excepted, and to restore the premises to their original state if the landlord requires it. That is the wording of the clause in the 2017 Kuala Lumpur High Court case discussed below.

In a factory or warehouse the list is longer than in an office:

  • office partitions, suspended ceilings, doors and air conditioning;
  • mezzanine floors, staircases and handrails;
  • pallet racking and the anchor bolts drilled into the floor slab;
  • extra distribution boards, cable trays, power points and lighting;
  • compressed air, water and process piping;
  • cold room panels, condensers and drains;
  • machine plinths, pits and floor openings;
  • exhaust ducts and fans cut through walls or the roof;
  • signboards, floor coatings and line markings;
  • stock, pallets, rubbish and process residue.

Original condition, bare shell or as it stands

Agreements use different standards. None of these labels is defined by statute, so the words of your agreement decide.

Standard What it usually means What to watch
Original condition at handover Return the unit as it was on the commencement date, fair wear and tear excepted You need a dated record of that condition, or the argument starts on day one
Bare shell or bare condition Strip back to the building shell It can catch items that were already there when you moved in, such as a previous tenant's office
As it stands, no reinstatement The landlord takes the unit back with your improvements Get it in writing, item by item, signed by the owner

In practice, yes. A Malaysian law firm's FAQ on commercial tenancies notes that most commercial tenancy agreements require the landlord's prior written consent before alterations, renovations or permanent fixtures, and that the tenant may have to reinstate at the end unless the landlord agrees otherwise in writing.

For a lease of more than three years registered at the land office, the National Land Code implies some terms unless the lease says otherwise: to keep the property in repair, to let the lessor inspect after reasonable notice, and not to sublet or part with possession without written consent (section 231). A consent requirement for alterations is not in that list, so it comes from the express clauses. For a tenancy of three years or less, everything depends on the signed agreement. Our tenancy agreement template guide shows where the alterations clause sits.

The landlord's letter does not replace the authorities. Under the Street, Drainage and Building Act 1974, a person who alters a building without the local authority's prior written permission can be fined up to RM25,000, and a Magistrate's Court can order the building to be altered or demolished (s.70(11)). The same Act presumes, until proved otherwise, that building work was carried out by the owner of the land (s.70(17)(a)). That is why careful landlords want to see drawings and approvals before a tenant starts.

Councils also expect the owner to sign off when a tenant applies. The Selayang council's form JB-B04(A) for temporary permits for factory additions asks for a consent letter from the building owner when the tenant applies, and for the owner's details and signature on the plans. Which works need plans and what happens when they are skipped is covered in our guide to illegal factory extensions.

Electrical work has its own rule: the Energy Commission requires contractors and wiremen carrying out electrical installation work to hold a valid licence it issues, and an installation that must be registered cannot be operated without a valid Certificate of Registration (Electricity Supply Act 1990, s.21). Keep every certificate your contractor issues: the landlord and the next tenant will ask for them.

  1. The scope of work, with drawings and the contractor's name.
  2. Who applies for and pays for council, Bomba and electrical approvals, and that copies go to the landlord.
  3. An item list: removed at the end, left in place, or left in place only if the landlord chooses at expiry.
  4. The reinstatement standard for each item, for example "remove racking, cut anchors flush and patch the floor".
  5. Any extra deposit held for the works.
  6. Insurance during the works and notice to the building insurer. See who insures what in a factory lease.
  7. Whether the landlord pays for, or credits, anything you leave behind.

Who owns the renovation when the tenancy ends?

Unless the agreement says otherwise, mostly the landlord. The National Land Code treats things attached to the earth, or permanently fastened to something attached to it, as part of the land (section 5). Section 3 of the Civil Law Act 1956 lets the courts apply English common law to decide whether an item is a fixture or a chattel, using a two stage test from Holland v Hodgson: the degree of annexation and the purpose of annexation. An item fixed to the land is presumed to be a fixture, an item resting on its own weight is presumed to be a chattel, and either presumption can be rebutted (Kevin Wu & Associates). The same article warns that improvements made by a tenant generally become the landlord's property and usually cannot be reclaimed when the tenancy ends.

Item How it is usually attached What to agree in writing
Steel mezzanine Bolted to the floor slab Stays, removed, or landlord decides at expiry
Office partitions, ceiling, air conditioning Built in Stays or removed; who repairs wall and ceiling damage
Pallet racking Anchored to the floor Removed, anchors cut and holes patched
Extra distribution boards and cabling Part of the building's wiring Stays or removed; who completes the electrical paperwork
Cold room Panels fixed, plant outside Removed, sold to the landlord, or left for the next tenant
Production machines standing on their own weight Not fixed Yours to remove; you repair any floor damage

The table shows how items are usually attached, not a legal ruling: the test is applied object by object. There is no automatic payment for improvements left behind. If you are spending heavily on a fit-out, negotiate the return before you start: a rent free fit-out period, a longer term, a renewal option or an agreed buy-back price. If the landlord sells, the fixtures go with the property; see what happens to your tenancy when the landlord sells.

Steel mezzanine bolted to a factory floor while a free-standing machine is wheeled out
IllustrationSteel mezzanine bolted to a factory floor while a free-standing machine is wheeled out

What condition must the factory be in when you hand it back?

First, whatever the agreement says. For a registered lease, the implied agreement to keep the property in repair (section 231(1)(b)) is measured against the state of repair "in which a prudent owner might reasonably be expected to keep his property" (section 5), and it does not require the building to be put into a better state of repair than it was in at the start of the lease (section 233). These implied terms apply only to registered leases and give way to express clauses. Most factory tenancies of three years or less rely only on the signed agreement.

Fair wear and tear

Deductions cannot be made for fair wear and tear (LH Low & Associates). In plain terms, normal ageing from the use the agreement allows is the landlord's cost, while damage is the tenant's. Faded paint and worn floor markings are typical of the first; slab edges cracked by forklifts, holes from racking anchors, chemical stains and a bent roller shutter are typical of the second. The handover record decides most of these arguments, which is why step 7 of our factory renting checklist asks you to photograph the unit on day one.

Returning the keys is not vacant possession

In Hong Poh Teck & 3 Ors v Effort Ezy Sdn Bhd ([2018] 2 AMR 833), the tenant of two units in Melaka wanted to remove the party wall between them. The owners agreed on condition that it reinstate the premises, obtain the structural approvals and return vacant possession at its own cost, and those terms went into the tenancy agreements. After the tenant fell behind on rent and the tenancies were terminated, it returned the keys and said it had cleared the premises. The Kuala Lumpur High Court held on 4 October 2017 that returning the keys without reinstating was not vacant possession, that the original state was shown by the structural plan approved by Majlis Bandaraya Melaka, that the "wall deposit" held by the owners was no defence, and that double rent applied under the Civil Law Act (judgment).

Section 28(4)(a) of the Civil Law Act 1956 makes a tenant holding over after the tenancy ends chargeable, at the landlord's option, with double the rent until possession is given up. So finish the works inside the term, or agree in writing an extra period and its rent before the expiry date.

How do you plan reinstatement before moving out?

  1. Collect the paper. The agreement, every consent letter, approvals and the handover record. List each alteration you made.
  2. Ask the landlord what should stay. A landlord re-letting the unit may want to keep the offices or the power upgrade. Get the answer item by item, in writing, signed by the owner.
  3. Inspect together before the works. Walk the unit with the landlord against the handover photographs and agree the scope.
  4. Price the scope. Get quotations for removal, floor and wall repair, repainting and cleaning. For anything that was built under approved plans, ask your architect or engineer whether removing it needs a submission too. In the Hong Poh Teck case, the agreement required the restoration to be backed by the authorities' approval.
  5. Do the works within the term. Heavy items such as mezzanines and cold rooms take time to strip, and floor patching needs time to cure.
  6. Hand over formally. Joint final inspection, a signed acceptance, final meter readings, final utility bills and the keys.
  7. Ask for the deposit in writing, attaching the signed acceptance.

Paying instead of doing the works

Some landlords prefer a sum in place of reinstatement, for instance when the next tenant wants the offices. If you agree, record the amount and state that it settles the reinstatement obligation in full, so the same item cannot be claimed again from the deposit.

Can the landlord keep the deposit for reinstatement, and how do you get it back?

A security deposit is refunded at the end of the tenancy, without interest, less any liabilities the tenant has incurred (PKNS legal briefing). The same briefing cites BBMB Kewangan Bhd v Kueh Teck Swee [2001] 2 AMR 1401: the landlord's right to forfeit depended on the express terms of the agreement, and because the tenant had not breached the specified covenants the landlord had to refund the deposit after deducting what it spent on repairs at expiry. Where the agreement does not allow the deposit to be used for repairs, the landlord's route is a claim for breach of contract, and if the damage is greater than the deposit, the landlord can sue for the balance.

Where an agreement lets the landlord forfeit the whole deposit for a breach, section 75 of the Contracts Act 1950 limits recovery to reasonable compensation not exceeding the sum named. In Cubic Electronics v Mars Telecommunications, a property sale case, the Federal Court held that a deposit is subject to section 75, that actual loss need not be proved in every case, and that legitimate interest and proportionality are relevant to what is reasonable (Allen & Gledhill).

On timing, the agreement decides; deposits are usually refunded within 30 to 60 days after the tenant leaves, and deductions such as unpaid rent, utilities, unauthorised work or damage beyond fair wear and tear must be reasonable and backed by proper evidence (LH Low & Associates).

If the landlord will not refund

  1. Write to the landlord with the signed handover record and ask for itemised deductions with quotations or invoices.
  2. Send a lawyer's letter of demand.
  3. If it goes to court, the Sessions Court has unlimited jurisdiction in landlord and tenant actions (Subordinate Courts Act 1948, s.65(1)(a)), and a First Class Magistrate hears civil claims up to RM100,000 (s.90). Your lawyer will choose the court.
  4. Mind the time limit: an action founded on a contract cannot be brought after six years from the date the cause of action accrued (Limitation Act 1953, s.6(1)(a)).

What changes for a factory or warehouse compared with an office or shop?

  • Heavier works. Mezzanines, racking anchors, machine plinths and roof openings leave structural traces that partitions in an office do not.
  • More approvals. Council plans or permits, the fire systems and the electrical installation can all be affected, and the approvals stay with the building after you leave.
  • Improvements the next tenant may value. A power upgrade or a set of offices can help the landlord re-let the unit, so leaving them in place is often negotiable.
  • Process residue. Oil, dust and chemical traces are part of the clean-up the landlord will inspect.
Landlord and tenant inspecting an empty factory together before the deposit is refunded
IllustrationLandlord and tenant inspecting an empty factory together before the deposit is refunded

Common mistakes

  • Relying on a verbal "okay" from the landlord's representative instead of a signed letter from the owner.
  • No dated photographs or inventory at handover.
  • Assuming that works the landlord approved never have to be removed.
  • Starting the works after expiry and paying double rent while they run.
  • Leaving council or electrical paperwork incomplete, so the landlord holds back the deposit.
  • Accepting a lump sum deduction with no breakdown.

Costs, tax and financing: more questions

How long does a landlord have to return a deposit in Malaysia?

There is no fixed statutory period for a factory tenancy; the agreement sets it. Deposits are usually refunded within 30 to 60 days after the tenant leaves. If the agreement is silent, ask in writing for the refund and an itemised list of deductions straight after handover.

Practical steps: more questions

Is fair wear and tear the tenant's responsibility?

No. Deductions cannot be made for fair wear and tear, which is the normal ageing that comes from the use the agreement allows. The tenant pays for damage beyond that, such as cracked slab edges, anchor holes or broken shutters.

Ms Teh Seok Hoon explains what to agree on reinstatement in a rented Klang factory, and Jason Low covers reinstatement works at the end of a tenancy in Rawang, Serendah and Shah Alam.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make structural changes to a factory after I rent it?

Yes, but only with the landlord's prior written consent and the council's written permission. Building plans must be signed by the owner, and altering a building without the local authority's permission can bring a fine of up to RM25,000 and an order to alter or demolish under section 70(11) of the Street, Drainage and Building Act 1974. Agree in writing who pays, who owns the work when the tenancy ends and whether you must remove it, and have an engineer check the structure first.

How can I protect my deposit when I rent a factory?

Put the rules in writing and keep evidence from day one. The agreement should say what the deposit may be used for and when it is refunded. At handover, record the unit with dated photos and meter readings, get written consent for every alteration with an agreed reinstatement scope, and pay rent and utility bills on time with receipts. At the end, do a joint inspection and sign a handover note. Deductions must be reasonable and evidenced, and fair wear and tear is not your cost.

What does reinstatement work mean?

Reinstatement work is the removal, repair and cleaning a tenant carries out at the end of a tenancy so the premises match the condition the agreement requires. In a factory it usually covers partitions, mezzanines, racking anchors, extra wiring and piping, signage and any damage beyond fair wear and tear. The exact scope comes from the reinstatement clause and any consent letters.

What is a reinstatement clause in a tenancy agreement?

It is the clause that tells the tenant what condition to return the premises in. A common form asks the tenant to yield up the premises in good and tenantable repair, fair wear and tear excepted, to remove its own fixtures and to restore the premises to their original state if the landlord requires it. Check whether it says "original condition", "bare shell" or lists specific items.

Do I have to remove renovations the landlord approved?

Often yes. Consent to carry out works is not the same as agreeing to keep them, and many agreements require approved alterations to be removed unless the landlord agrees otherwise in writing. Put the answer for each item into the consent letter before you start.

Who owns the renovation after the tenancy ends in Malaysia?

Things permanently fixed to the building are treated as part of the land under section 5 of the National Land Code, so they generally belong to the landlord. Free-standing equipment resting on its own weight is presumed to stay yours. The agreement can change this, so state which items you may remove and whether any are paid for.

Can a landlord keep my deposit for reinstatement?

Only as the agreement allows. A landlord can deduct the reasonable, evidenced cost of reinstatement and repairs the tenant is responsible for, but not fair wear and tear. If the agreement does not allow deductions, the landlord has to claim for breach of contract instead, and a forfeiture of the full deposit is limited to reasonable compensation under section 75 of the Contracts Act 1950.

Not for works that need approval. Altering a building without the local authority's prior written permission can lead to a fine of up to RM25,000 and a court order to alter or demolish under section 70(11) of the Street, Drainage and Building Act 1974. Ask the council, through your architect or engineer, what your works need before you start.

FactoryHub is dedicated to helping every client find the right factory or warehouse. Before you sign for a unit you plan to fit out, call or WhatsApp Peter Tan (REN 12771) at 016-666 6872 to go through the alterations and reinstatement terms with you.