Key Takeaways

  • A buyer who backs out usually loses the deposit, but only up to what is reasonable. In 2018 the Federal Court held that a deposit is subject to section 75 of the Contracts Act 1950: the seller may keep it without proving actual loss, and the buyer carries the burden of proving the sum is unreasonable.
  • The letter of offer can bind both sides before any SPA is signed. A 2022 High Court decision upheld a letter of offer that set the price, payment terms, conditions and completion date, and let the seller keep an earnest deposit the letter called "non-refundable".
  • The deposit comes back only where the documents or the law say so: a loan, consent or title condition that fails without the buyer's fault, a seller who defaults, or a sum the buyer proves is unreasonable. A rejected loan alone does not refund it.
  • Run the anti-scam checks before any payment: an official title search, the seller's identity against the title, the agent's registration, an independently verified lawyer, and a payee that is a law firm or estate agency client account checked on the police Semak Mule portal.
  • Keys are handed over at completion, after the full price is paid, typically a few working days after full settlement, unless the SPA gives earlier access in writing.

A factory sale in Malaysia moves large sums long before the title changes hands. On a RM3 million to RM20 million detached or semi-detached factory, the earnest deposit at the offer and the top-up to 10% at the SPA can reach seven figures, so who keeps that money when one side walks away matters as much as the price. This guide explains how the deposits work, when they are forfeited or refunded, what the letter of offer and the SPA should say, which costs a seller can pass to a buyer, when the keys change hands, and how to avoid the scams that target property deals. It is general information, not legal advice: have your own lawyer read the documents before you pay anything.

How are deposits paid when you buy a factory in Malaysia?

A sub-sale usually has two payments before completion. With the letter of offer, the buyer pays an earnest deposit, which one Malaysian law firm puts at 2% to 3% of the price, with the SPA to be signed within 14 to 21 working days. On signing the SPA, the buyer tops the deposit up to 10%. The balance is then due within the completion period, which the same firm describes as typically three months from the agreement date or the consent date, with an automatic one month extension bearing interest, usually 8% a year.

None of these figures is fixed by law. Another firm stresses that the amount of the deposit "ultimately depends upon the terms agreed between the parties". For a factory, where the seller is often a company and the title may need state consent, the timetable is frequently longer, and every date should be written into the documents.

Stage Typical payment Who should hold it What decides a refund
Letter of offer Earnest deposit, commonly 2% to 3% A registered estate agency's client account, or the seller's lawyer as stakeholder The wording of the letter of offer
SPA signed Balance deposit to reach 10% The seller's lawyer as stakeholder, until the conditions are met The conditions precedent and the default clause in the SPA
Completion Balance 90%, in cash or from the buyer's bank Paid against the transfer and the redemption of any seller's loan The completion and extension clauses

Earnest deposit, deposit or part payment?

The label matters less than what the payment does. The Federal Court in Cubic Electronics Sdn Bhd v Mars Telecommunications Sdn Bhd put it this way: money paid in advance only as part payment of the price is generally recoverable after a breach, but a deposit, which is also a guarantee that the buyer will perform, generally is not. Once a payment has "the dual characteristics of earnest money and part payment, it is a deposit", and a deposit is subject to section 75 of the Contracts Act 1950.

The buyer backs out after paying the deposit: is it forfeited?

Usually yes, if the letter of offer or the SPA provides for forfeiture and the buyer is the party in breach. The limit is reasonableness, and the burden of proving unreasonableness sits with the buyer.

What the Federal Court decided in Cubic Electronics

The case was about industrial property: land in Melaka with plant and machinery, sold by the liquidators of a company. The buyer offered RM90 million with an earnest deposit of RM1 million. The acceptance required the SPA to be signed within 30 days, failing which the deposit would be forfeited "as agreed liquidated damages and not by way of penalty". The buyer did not sign, asked for extensions, and paid a further RM2 million of earnest deposits to get them. When it asked for yet another extension, the liquidators refused and forfeited all the sums paid.

In a judgment dated 21 November 2018, the Federal Court let the seller keep all of it. The principles it set out:

  1. Section 75 allows reasonable compensation "irrespective of whether actual loss or damage is proven". The seller does not have to prove its loss first.
  2. The seller must show a breach and a clause naming the sum payable on breach. It is then entitled to a sum not exceeding the amount stated in the contract.
  3. If there is a dispute about what is reasonable, the burden of proof falls on the defaulting party.
  4. A sum is unreasonable if it is "extravagant and unconscionable" compared with the highest loss that could flow from the breach. The court weighs the seller's legitimate interest and proportionality.

On the facts, the court noted the RM3 million forfeited was only 3.33% of the price, and that the seller's lost chance to negotiate with other parties and its interest in a timely completion were legitimate interests. The buyer offered no evidence that the sum was excessive, so it failed. The judgment also records the Privy Council's older remark that there is "nothing unusual or extortionate in a 10% deposit on a contract for the sale of land".

Before the SPA: is the letter of offer binding?

It can be. In Dato' Khoo Chee Hiong v TH Ladang (Sabah & Sarawak) Sdn Bhd (High Court, Kuala Lumpur, 29 November 2022), the buyers argued that a letter of offer was only an agreement to agree because a formal agreement was still to be signed. The court disagreed. The letter set out the parties, the subject matter, a total consideration of RM38 million, the payment terms, the conditions precedent and the completion date, and the buyers had paid an earnest deposit of RM1,140,000. The court found the letter binding and gave effect to the words "non-refundable earnest deposit".

That case was a share sale, but the reasoning carries over to a factory offer letter: the more complete it is, the more likely it binds both sides. For a buyer, the protections you need must be in the offer letter, not saved for the SPA. For a seller, a clear forfeiture clause in the offer letter is what lets you keep the earnest deposit if the buyer never signs.

When does the buyer get the deposit back?

Only where the documents or the law say so. The common cases:

  • A condition fails without the buyer's fault: the loan is not approved within the stated time, state consent is refused, or the title search shows a problem the seller cannot clear. The refund exists only if the clause provides it. As one law firm warns, "Do not assume 'loan rejected' automatically means 'deposit refunded'."
  • The seller defaults or misrepresents the property, for example the title, the approvals or what is included in the sale.
  • The sum kept is unreasonable under section 75. After Cubic Electronics, the buyer has to prove this with evidence.

For a factory, add conditions that match your use: the incoming power you need, zoning that allows your process, and approved plans for any extension you are paying for. If the title is leasehold with a restriction in interest, see our guide to state consent for a leasehold factory and tie the refund to the consent being refused.

The seller backs out: what can the buyer do?

Once a binding offer or SPA exists, the seller cannot simply return the money and sell to someone else at a higher price. The buyer can usually choose between two routes:

  • Specific performance, asking the court to order the sale to go through. Under section 11(2) of the Specific Relief Act 1950, the court presumes, unless the contrary is proved, that the breach of a contract to transfer immovable property cannot be adequately relieved by money, as a paper in INSPEN's Journal of Valuation and Property Services explains.
  • Ending the contract and claiming the deposit back, together with whatever agreed compensation the SPA provides for seller default.

Some offer letters also state what a withdrawing seller must pay, for example the earnest deposit back plus an agreed sum. Whether that applies, and how much, depends entirely on what is negotiated and signed. A seller who accepts an earnest deposit and then aborts before the SPA may also owe its own agent: under the Malaysian Estate Agency Standards, the agency is entitled to 50% of its full fee or 50% of the earnest deposit, whichever is lower, plus disbursements.

A factory buyer points at the sale documents while the seller pulls the keys back across a meeting table
IllustrationA factory buyer points at the sale documents while the seller pulls the keys back across a meeting table

Who keeps the forfeited deposit, the owner or the agent?

The owner keeps it, less the agent's share that the Board's standards allow. Standard 4 of the Malaysian Estate Agency Standards, issued by the Board of Valuers, Appraisers, Estate Agents and Property Managers, sets these rules:

Situation What the client's agency may claim
The other party aborts before the SPA and the client forfeits the deposit 50% of the full fee or 50% of the forfeited deposit, whichever is lower, plus disbursements
The client accepts an earnest deposit, then aborts before the SPA 50% of the full fee or 50% of the earnest deposit, whichever is lower, plus disbursements
The client aborts after an unconditional SPA, or after a conditional SPA becomes unconditional The full fee plus disbursements

The same standards say an agency may deduct its fee from the earnest deposit only after an unconditional SPA is signed and with the client's prior written consent. Client money must be paid into a client's account, and money may be drawn from that account only in favour of the vendor, the purchaser, or a party the client has authorised.

What should the letter of offer and the SPA say?

Clause What to write Why it matters
Parties The seller's name exactly as on the title; for a company, the board resolution and the authorised signatory Fraud and authority problems start here
Property Title and lot number, land area, tenure, land use category and express condition, taken from an official search You are buying the land shown on the register
Deposit The amount, whether it is an earnest deposit, a deposit or part payment, and whether it is refundable Courts give effect to plain words such as "non-refundable"
Stakeholder Who holds the money and when it may be released Money in a law firm or agency client account is easier to recover
SPA deadline The date the SPA must be signed by, and how extensions are granted Missing it without an agreed extension can forfeit the earnest deposit
Conditions Loan approval within a stated period, state consent, a clean title search, any approval your use needs, each with a refund if it fails without your fault A refund exists only if the clause gives one
Seller default What the seller pays if it withdraws, and the buyer's right to specific performance Keeps the remedies balanced
Completion The length of the completion period, when it starts, the extension and the interest rate Late interest applies only as the SPA states
Vacant possession The handover date, empty or with a tenant, keys, access cards and gate remotes Avoids arguments on handover day
Fixtures A schedule with photographs: transformer, switchboard, cranes, racking, generator What is not listed is not sold
Costs Who pays each fee and duty, and how outgoings are apportioned Avoids last minute demands

Our guide to factory SPA clauses walks through the whole agreement; the clauses above are the ones that decide what happens to the deposit. For the full purchase sequence, see how to buy a factory in Malaysia.

How do you avoid scams in a factory deal?

Land and property fraud is not rare. The police Commercial Crime Investigation Department reported 489 land scam cases from 2021 to the end of 2023, with losses of RM299.6 million, and warned buyers against land offered below market value. In a 2024 High Court case in Kuala Lumpur over a plot in Johor, an agent was found to hold a RM1.2 million earnest deposit that never reached the owner, and the person who drafted the sale papers was found to be falsely holding herself out as a lawyer.

Checks to finish before you pay anything:

  1. Search the title yourself. An official search (carian rasmi) shows the registered owner, the land details and any charge, caveat or restriction. The Petaling land office lists RM50 for an official search and RM30 for a private search; the official search carries the Land Administrator's verification stamp. Through Selangor's e-Tanah system, an official search takes one working day to process. Search again shortly before completion.
  2. Match the seller to the title. The identity card or company registration must match the registered owner. For a company seller, confirm the directors and get the board resolution approving the sale.
  3. Check the agent. Ask for the agent's registration number (REN, PEA or REA) and the firm's name, and check them with the Board. A registered estate agent must keep a client's account and pay client money into it.
  4. Verify the lawyer independently. Find the law firm's contact details yourself, not from a message you were sent, and speak to the lawyer handling the file.
  5. Check the payee before every transfer. Pay only into a law firm's or registered agency's client account, never an individual's personal account. Run the account number, phone number or company name through the police Semak Mule portal. If bank details "change" by message or email, confirm by calling a number you already had.
  6. Be wary of urgency and discounts. A price far below the registered deals in the same area, or pressure to pay before a search, are warning signs.

If money has already gone to a scammer, call your bank and the National Scam Response Centre at 997 within 24 hours of finding out, and lodge a police report.

A buyer checks a land title and an identity card with a magnifying glass before paying a factory deposit
IllustrationA buyer checks a land title and an identity card with a magnifying glass before paying a factory deposit

Can the seller ask the buyer to bear some of the costs?

It can ask, and most cost terms in a sub-sale SPA are negotiable, but several are fixed by law, and any cost you agree to take on is really part of the price.

Cost Who bears it Basis
Stamp duty on the transfer The buyer, as transferee Stamp Act 1949, Third Schedule
Stamp duty on the bank charge The buyer, as chargor Same schedule
RPGT on the seller's gain The seller, as disposer LHDN
RPGT retention of 3%, 5% or 7% Withheld by the buyer from the price and paid to LHDN within 60 days of disposal; a 10% increase applies if it is not paid LHDN
Quit rent, assessment, utilities Apportioned to the agreed completion or handover date SPA practice described by both law firms cited above
Seller's loan redemption Paid out of the price to the seller's bank It is the seller's debt and reduces what the seller receives
State consent fee As the SPA provides Agree it before signing

Our legal fees and stamp duty calculator estimates the lawyer's scale fee and the transfer duty for your price.

The request to watch for is a "nett price", where the buyer pays the seller's RPGT, agent fee or other costs on top of the price. Treat it as a price increase and compare the real total with registered deals. It does not change who LHDN treats as the disposer. If you agree, write each cost and its cap into the SPA.

When are the keys handed over?

At completion, after the full price has been paid or deemed paid, unless the SPA says otherwise. One law firm notes that in a sub-sale the buyer "does not automatically receive the keys immediately after signing the SPA"; another puts vacant possession at usually 3 to 5 working days after full settlement. With a three month completion period and a one month extension, that is typically three to four months after the SPA, and longer if state consent is needed.

For a factory, handover is more than a set of keys:

  • Inspect the building and the fixtures schedule before the final payment is released.
  • Collect every key, access card, gate remote and alarm code, including the electrical room and any substation room that belongs to the owner.
  • Record the TNB and water meter readings on the day and arrange the change of account.
  • If the factory is sold with a tenant, the tenancy and the tenant's deposit pass to you instead of the keys to the floor, so read the tenancy agreement first.
  • Early access for fit-out before completion happens only if the seller agrees in writing, usually as a licence in the SPA covering insurance, liability and what happens if the sale fails.

Related questions are answered in separate guides: entering a caveat on the title, selling a factory that still has a bank loan, a bank valuation below the price, and agent commission.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an earnest deposit refundable in Malaysia?

Only if the letter of offer says so or a refund condition is triggered, such as a loan or consent condition that fails without the buyer's fault. The High Court has enforced a binding letter of offer that described the earnest deposit as "non-refundable". If the buyer simply changes its mind, the seller can usually keep the deposit, subject to the reasonableness test in section 75 of the Contracts Act 1950.

Who keeps the deposit if the buyer backs out?

The seller keeps it as compensation, and it does not have to prove its actual loss first; the buyer can only recover it by proving the amount is unreasonable. If an estate agency acted for the seller and the buyer aborts before the SPA, the agency may claim 50% of its full fee or 50% of the forfeited deposit, whichever is lower, plus disbursements. The seller keeps the rest.

Does the seller lose money if the buyer pulls out?

Often it does: the factory was off the market, other buyers moved on and holding costs continued. That is why the law allows a seller to keep a reasonable deposit without proving each ringgit of loss. The Federal Court treated the seller's lost chance to deal with other parties and its interest in a timely completion as legitimate interests the deposit protects.

What does it mean if a deposit is forfeited?

The party who paid it loses it, and the other party keeps it as agreed compensation for the breach, which usually ends the deal. In Malaysia a forfeiture clause is read under section 75 of the Contracts Act 1950, so the sum kept cannot exceed what the contract names and must amount to reasonable compensation.

My loan was rejected. Do I lose my factory deposit?

That depends on your documents. If the letter of offer or SPA makes the purchase subject to loan approval within a stated period and provides a refund when the loan is rejected, the deposit comes back under that clause. Without such a clause, a rejected loan does not by itself entitle the buyer to a refund.

Can the seller back out after accepting my earnest deposit?

Not freely, if the letter of offer is binding. The buyer can ask the court for specific performance, which the Specific Relief Act 1950 presumes is the proper remedy for a contract to transfer land, or end the contract and claim the deposit back with any agreed compensation.

What is delivery of vacant possession?

It means the seller hands over the property free of the seller, tenants and other occupiers, with the keys and control, so the buyer can use it. In a sub-sale this normally happens at completion, after full payment. Where a factory is sold with a tenant, the tenancy passes to the buyer instead.

Can I start renovating the factory before completion?

Only with the seller's written agreement, usually a licence in the SPA. It should state who insures the building, who is liable for damage, and what happens to the works and the access if the sale does not complete.

FactoryHub is dedicated to helping every client find the right factory or warehouse. To talk through a factory purchase or sale, call Peter Tan (REN 12771) at 016-666 6872 or Jason Low (PEA 1478) at 012-288 1834.