Key Takeaways
- A bank lends on the lower of the purchase price and its panel valuer's figure, so a bank valuation below your SPA price means a smaller loan and more cash from you. Bank Muamalat's SME property financing, for example, is capped against the open market value or the SPA price, "whichever is lower".
- The valuer must estimate market value from evidence. Under the Malaysian Valuation Standards, asking prices rank sixth in the order of evidence, behind recent sales of similar properties. A price agreed from asking prices is the usual cause of a gap.
- When the valuation comes in low you can pay the difference, renegotiate, ask the bank to review it with registered comparables, try another bank, or walk away, but only if your SPA has a loan condition with a refund.
- Company loans are mostly turned down over cash flow, accounts, credit history in CCRIS, collateral, or a property that falls outside the bank's product. Rejected SME applicants can ask MyKNP at CGC, free of charge, to explain the reasons and point to other financing.
- Age alone does not cut a valuation. Visible defects, extensions without approval, a missing CCC and a short remaining lease do.
Why Is the Bank Valuation Lower Than the Price I Agreed?
Because the seller and the valuer answer different questions. The seller asks what a keen buyer might pay. The bank's panel valuer has to estimate market value for the bank and defend it with evidence.
The Malaysian Valuation Standards, Seventh Edition, in force since 1 June 2025 as subsidiary legislation under the Valuers, Appraisers, Estate Agents and Property Managers Act 1981, define market value as the estimated amount an asset should exchange for on the valuation date between a willing buyer and a willing seller in an arm's length transaction, after proper marketing, where both acted knowledgeably, prudently and without compulsion (MVS 4). Valuations for a loan fall under MVS 12, Valuations for Financing Purposes.
Asking prices are weak evidence
MVS 7.3.6 sets the order of evidence a valuer relies on:
| Rank | Evidence |
|---|---|
| 1 | A recent sale of the property itself |
| 2 | Recent transactions of similar properties |
| 3 | Recent deals agreed between buyer and seller but not yet registered |
| 4 | Binding offers |
| 5 | Published sources or databases |
| 6 | Asking prices |
| 7 to 9 | Older evidence, indirect evidence, and deals for other property types or places |
The valuer adjusts each comparable for the ways it differs from your factory and, under MVS 7.2.1.1(j), must not simply average the results: the opinion rests on the most comparable adjusted evidence. If the price you agreed is above every recent sale of a similar factory nearby, the report will not reach it, however many asking prices sit at that level.
The registered range is wide
JPPH-registered transactions in Klang and Port Klang show why one factory's figure needs close comparables. In the 24 months to August 2026, semi-detached factories had a median price of RM5 million, a typical range of RM3.5 million to RM7.58 million and RM337 psf of land. Detached factories had a median of RM14.9 million, a typical range of RM8.65 million to RM19 million and RM270 psf of land. Within that spread, land size, tenure, power supply, specs and condition decide where a single factory sits, and the valuer has to show which deals support the number.
What else the valuer tells the bank
- Title details. MVS 6.2.2(j) requires the valuer to ascertain the title details, so the land category, express conditions and any restriction in interest appear in the report.
- Visible defects. The valuer does not carry out a structural survey but must draw attention to any visible major defects (MVS 6.2.2(d)).
- Marketability. A paper on the Seventh Edition presented to the ASEAN Valuers Association congress in November 2025 notes that bankers in Malaysia usually ask for a marketability factor scored 1 to 10, although MVS does not require one. Some banks also ask for a forced sale value, which is a basis other than market value (MVS 5). A special-purpose factory that few buyers could use is likely to score lower than a standard semi-detached unit in an established park.
Is a Bank Valuation Accurate?
It is a professional opinion, not a measurement. A formal report must follow the Malaysian Valuation Standards and be signed by a registered valuer; the data must be verified, and the adjustments must be "consistent, supportable and reasonable" (MVS 8.3.3). Two valuers can still reach different figures from the same deals, because picking and adjusting comparables takes judgement.
Two points matter for a buyer:
- An indicative value is not a valuation. MVS 12.3.7 notes that Malaysian banks often ask valuers for an indicative value to start loan processing, and valuers carry no professional liability for it. MVS 12.3.8 requires a disclaimer that the figure may change once the formal report is done after an inspection. Treat a figure given by phone or WhatsApp as a guide only.
- The report is written for the bank. The bank instructs the panel valuer and uses the figure to size the loan. You usually pay the fee, but you are not the valuer's client, so any request to revisit the figure goes through your banker.
Bank Valuation Below the SPA Price: What Are Your Options?
How the shortfall works
Banks set the margin on the lower of price and value. Bank Muamalat caps total financing at 105% "against OMV or Sales and Purchase Agreement (whichever is lower)", and HSBC's Business Premises Financing disclosure sheet works its margin off the "purchase price/Open Market Value".
An illustration with round numbers, not a real deal: you agree RM5,000,000 for a semi-detached factory and expect an 85% loan of RM4,250,000. The valuer reports RM4,600,000. At 85% of the lower figure the loan becomes RM3,910,000, so you must find RM340,000 more than planned, on top of the 10% deposit and the costs.
That cash goes into the difference sum: the part of the balance the loan does not cover. In a typical subsale SPA the purchaser should pay the difference sum without delay, because the bank will not release the loan until it is paid, and if the balance is not paid by the completion date or the extended date, the vendor may forfeit the deposit (National House Buyers Association, Understanding an SPA).
Six ways to handle it
| Option | When it works | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Pay the gap in cash | You have the cash and still want the factory | Time it to the completion date and keep a buffer for legal fees and stamp duty |
| Renegotiate the price | The price is above the registered evidence | Show the seller the registered sales behind the gap |
| Ask the bank for a review | You hold registered sales the valuer may have missed | Send close comparables (same park, type and size) through your banker; a review is the bank's decision |
| Try another bank | The first report relied on weak or distant comparables | Each bank uses its own panel, a new formal valuation means a new fee, and CCRIS reports include credit application details |
| Change the facility | The company can carry more borrowing | Some SME property packages add working capital on top of the property loan; it is still debt the company must service |
| Withdraw | The SPA makes the loan a condition and you are inside its time limit | Without such a clause, failing to complete puts the deposit at risk |
Compare lenders first on the commercial and factory loan rates page, which sets out indicative rates, margins and tenures by bank.
What the valuation costs
The Board of Valuers, Appraisers, Estate Agents and Property Managers publishes the scale of fees (Seventh Schedule, Rule 48). For capital valuations on an improved value basis the fee is 1/4% on the first RM100,000, 1/5% on the residue up to RM2 million, 1/6% up to RM7 million, 1/8% up to RM15 million and 1/10% up to RM50 million, with a minimum of RM400 per property. Expenses and tax come on top.
| Value | Scale fee |
|---|---|
| RM3 million | about RM5,717 |
| RM5 million | RM9,050 |
| RM10 million | about RM16,133 |
| RM20 million | about RM27,383 |
Ask your bank who pays the fee and whether any of it comes back if the loan does not go ahead; this differs between banks and offers.
My Factory Loan Was Rejected: What Next?
Act inside the SPA timetable: a rejection does not stop the completion clock.
- Ask for the reason. In 2013 the Association of Banks in Malaysia announced that participating banks would tell SMEs why a loan was turned down, using a checklist that covers areas such as weaknesses of the business plan, collateral adequacy and credit history (The Star).
- Use MyKNP. MyKNP, run by Bank Negara Malaysia, CGC and AKPK, gives unsuccessful SME financing applicants free help: clarification of the rejection reasons, how to improve eligibility and information on alternative financing. SME applicants contact CGC on 03-7880 0088 (BNM announcement, 21 August 2019).
- Pull your CCRIS report. CCRIS shows a borrower's financing and repayment history over the past 12 months, and borrowers can see it online through eCCRIS for free. If a bank reported something wrongly, it must correct it. BNM stresses that CCRIS is only one source; the lender makes the decision.
- Tell the seller's side early. Check whether your SPA lets you extend completion, or end the contract with a refund, when the loan is refused, and serve any notice the clause requires on time. The factory SPA guide lists the clauses to look for.
- Fix the cause, then reapply to a bank whose product fits both the company and the factory.
Why Do Banks Reject Company Borrowers?
| Reason | What the bank sees | What helps |
|---|---|---|
| Cash flow too thin | Operating cash flow cannot carry existing debt plus the new instalment | A cash flow projection that shows how the instalment is paid. Maybank told FMT that SMEs must show adequate cash flow and clear projections (FMT, 2022) |
| Poor documentation | Late, unaudited or inconsistent accounts | Audited accounts, current management accounts and bank statements that match them. Samenta named poor documentation and unfavourable financial results as the key reasons SMEs fail to get loans |
| Losses or falling results | Recent losses or shrinking revenue | Explain one-off items, show the recovery in management accounts, offer guarantees or a bigger cash contribution |
| Credit history | Late payments or undeclared facilities in CCRIS | Settle arrears, correct errors, declare every facility |
| Collateral | A valuation shortfall, title issues, unapproved works | Benchmark the price and check the title, CCC and approved plans first |
| Property outside the product | A special-purpose building, an unfinished building, or a purchase only to let | Bank Muamalat's SME product takes flatted or standardised light industrial buildings and warehouses in industrial areas, but not special-purpose factory buildings. HSBC's Business Premises Financing for an existing building requires it to be fully completed with a CCC and at least 50% owner-occupied |
| Ownership | A foreign-controlled company | Some SME products need Malaysian control: Bank Muamalat asks for at least 51% held by Malaysians, and Hong Leong's Business Mortgage is for SMEs with at least 51% Malaysian shareholding |
Can a New or Loss-Making Company Get a Factory Loan?
Yes, but the bank will lean on something other than the company's own record: the directors' track record and guarantees, a larger cash contribution, a related company that is already profitable, or a guarantee scheme.
- Guarantee schemes. CGC's BNM-CGC PG/-i Syarikat Pemula for start-up companies covers capital expenditure and working capital up to RM5 million, for up to 7 years, with 80% guarantee cover and a guarantee fee of 1.50% a year. CGC's BizJamin/-i 2.0 lists asset purchase among its purposes, with guarantees of up to RM5.0 million per SME for up to 15 years, cover of 30% to 80% and a fee of 0.50% to 4.20% a year. Both need at least 51% Malaysian shareholding and go through a participating bank. Ask whether a factory purchase and its tenure fit the scheme before you plan around it.
- A holding company. UOB BizProperty accepts an investment holding company set up to buy the property, and its calculator caps an operating company at 90% of the purchase price.
- A loss-making company. Show why the loss happened, what has changed and how the instalment will be paid. Banks lend on the ability to repay, so a one-off loss with a credible recovery reads differently from a falling trend.
The name you buy in also changes tax and resale. Our partner site's guide to buying a Klang factory under a company or personal name covers that choice.
What Documents Do I Need for a Factory Loan?
Two packs: the company and the property. For a Sdn Bhd, CIMB's SME Biz Property Financing asks for the NRIC (or passport for non-Malaysians), the latest three years' audited accounts and management accounts, the latest six months' bank statements, and evidence of the purchase such as the title, SPA or letter of offer. Sole proprietors and partnerships give their business registration, three years' management accounts, six months' statements and three years' tax returns instead. Your banker's own checklist will add company records such as SSM documents.
For the property, prepare the title search, the approved building plans and the CCC or CF. The CCC guide for factory buyers explains what to check.
Does an Old Factory Get a Lower Valuation?
Not because of the year alone. The valuer compares your factory with similar ones, so an older semi-detached factory in an established park is measured against other older units there. What pulls an older factory down is what age often brings:
- Visible defects such as roof leaks, cracked floor slabs or corroded steel, which the valuer must flag (MVS 6.2.2(d)).
- Extensions or conversions without approval, or a CCC or CF that does not match the building on site. HSBC's Business Premises Financing, for example, finances an existing building only when it is fully completed with a CCC.
- A short remaining lease on leasehold land. Ask each bank how much remaining term it needs at the end of the loan; policies differ.
- Specs that have fallen behind: a small power supply, low eaves or a floor that cannot take today's loads.
Each bank sets its own rules on building age, remaining lease and tenure, so ask before you sign. For everything else that moves a factory's value, see how much is my factory worth.
How to Raise Your Approval Chances Before You Sign
- Benchmark the price against JPPH-registered deals for the same factory type and area, not against asking prices.
- Ask two or three banks for an indicative value before you make the offer, knowing it is not binding.
- Write a loan condition into the offer and the SPA: a time limit, how many banks, and a full refund if the loan is refused or approved below a stated amount.
- Check eCCRIS, settle arrears and declare every facility.
- Bring the audited accounts up to date and prepare a cash flow projection that shows the instalment covered.
- Collect the title search, approved plans and CCC before you apply, and settle any unapproved works with the seller.
- Match the product to the purchase: owner-occupied or let, property type, completed or not, and who owns the company.
- Keep a cash buffer for a shortfall plus the valuation, legal and stamp duty costs.
This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Ask your lawyer about SPA clauses and your banker about the facility.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should I do if the bank valuation is lower than my offer?
First work out the gap in cash: the bank lends its margin on the lower figure. Then choose between paying the difference, renegotiating with the seller using registered comparables, asking the bank for a review, or trying another bank. If your SPA has a loan condition, check its deadline before you decide.
Is a bank valuation the same as market value?
A valuation for a loan is based on market value under the Malaysian Valuation Standards, but it is one valuer's opinion for the bank on a given date. Banks may also ask for a forced sale value or a marketability score, which are not market value. Your eventual selling price can differ from both.
Can I appeal a low bank valuation?
Not to the valuer directly, because the bank is the client. Ask your banker to pass the valuer recent registered sales of similar factories nearby. Whether the figure is reviewed is the bank's decision.
Will a different bank give a higher valuation?
It may, because each bank uses its own panel and valuers can weigh comparables differently. If the price is above all the registered evidence, a second report is likely to land close to the first, and each formal valuation carries its own fee.
Do I lose my deposit if my factory loan is rejected?
It depends on the SPA. A factory SPA is a negotiated contract, so a refund on loan rejection applies only if the SPA provides for it and you follow its notice and time limits. Without such a clause, failing to pay the balance by the completion date can allow the seller to forfeit the deposit.
Can a newly set up Sdn Bhd get a factory loan?
Yes, but expect the bank to ask for directors' guarantees, a larger cash contribution or a guarantee scheme. CGC's start-up company guarantee covers capital expenditure up to RM5 million with 80% cover, and is applied for through a participating bank.
How much does a bank valuation of a factory cost?
Under the Board's scale for capital valuations on an improved value basis, a RM5 million factory costs RM9,050 and a RM10 million factory about RM16,133, before expenses and tax. The minimum fee is RM400 per property.
Talk to Us
FactoryHub is dedicated to helping every client find the right factory or warehouse. Before you sign, Peter Tan (REN 12771, 016-666 6872) or Jason Low (PEA 1478, 012-288 1834), both registered with BOVAEP under CID Realtors Sdn Bhd, can check an asking price against the registered deals in the area.
